Garden Covers: Mulch vs Beach Stone Landscaping

As gardeners, we are constantly seeking ways to enhance the growth and health of our plants. The use of ground covers like mulch and beach stone can have a significant impact on the vitality of our gardens. Both have their pros and cons and can affect how you look after your garden.

Mulch

Natural Mulch
Cedar Mulch
Black Mulch
Red Mulch

Pros of Mulch

Enhanced Growth
Research suggests that using mulch can significantly accelerate the growth of trees and plants.

Water Conservation
Mulch reduces water evaporation, resulting in reduced watering needs and lower water expenses.

Increased Nutrients
As organic mulch decomposes, it releases nutrients that are essential for plant health and vitality.

Weed Control
Mulch acts as a barrier, preventing weed seeds from germinating and leading to a significant reduction in weed growth.

Optimal Temperature Regulation
Mulch helps to insulate plants, keeping them warm during winter and cool during summer.

Soil Protection
Mulch minimizes soil erosion by up to 85%, and its presence discourages compaction caused by foot traffic.

Cons of Mulch

Regular Replacement
Depending on the type of mulch used, it may need to be replaced every one to four years, incurring recurring costs and time investment.

Why Natural Beats Dyed Mulch for Your Garden

Natural Mulch + Cedar Mulch: If you’re all about organic gardening, you’ll probably lean towards natural or cedar mulch. Natural mulch is just the straight-up earthy stuff like fallen leaves, straw, or wood chips. It mixes in with your garden dirt and breaks down over time, giving back some goodness to the soil. Cedar mulch is pretty great, too – it lasts longer, smells nice, and keeps the bugs away. These are my number one choice for garden design.

Black Mulch + Red Mulch: While they can make your garden pop — black mulch fits right in with sleek, modern designs — I usually give them a pass unless someone specifically asks for them. These mulches are full of dyes, and let’s not even talk about the mess they can leave on your clothes if you’re not careful.

Beach Stone

Beach Stone

Pros of Beach Stone

Low Maintenance
Rocks rarely require replacement, leading to long-lasting ground cover.

Cost-Effective
Due to their durability, rocks are generally a more cost-effective mulching option.

Fire-Resistance
In areas prone to wildfires, nonflammable rocks offer a safer alternative.

Wind Erosion Prevention
Heavy rocks act as a barrier against soil erosion in windy environments.

Cons of Beach Stone

Increased Soil Temperature
Rocks tend to elevate soil temperature, potentially causing stress and dehydration in plants.

Limited Nutritional Value
Rocks do not contribute to plant growth or soil health.

Increased Weed Maintenance
Over time, wind may blow soil particles between rocks, creating spaces for weed growth. Can be difficult to remove weeds if they establish.

Conclusion: Weighing Your Ground Cover Options

Choosing between mulch and beach stone really comes down to what works best for your garden. Think about your local weather, what your garden needs, how much time you want to spend on upkeep, and the look you’re going for.

Mulch is great for giving your plants a boost and sprucing up your garden’s look, but you’ll need to replace it now and then.

Rocks, though, are pretty much a one-time thing — you set them down, and they’re good to go, saving you effort in the long run. They also have their own look and practical pluses.

Take a good look at your garden and decide what it needs most. No matter if it’s mulch or stones, the right ground cover can make all the difference to your garden’s health and growth.